Reading the Maps (Mark 7:24-30)
Tuesday, September 8, 2009 at 09:29AM Each year I attended Sunday school, the curriculum changed to reflect the growth of reading skills for the young student, however, there were four consistent elements to my childhood Sunday school memories:
Loving and dedicated women and men who took the task of teaching the faith seriously enough to speak of God’s love and grace, even when it took every bit of their own love and grace to keep track of the unruly kids in their care;
Flannel-graph, the Youtube of pre-technological Sunday school;
Kool-Aid (in small town Kansas churches, if you have a jug of Kool-Aid, you can teach Sunday school. If you have a mini-van as well, you can lead the youth group.)
Bible Maps.
Maps of the ancient biblical world are found in fewer Sunday school classrooms, most of them treasured and torn from years of wear and tear. Today, one can go online and reproduce for free just about any Bible map you could want, or if you are really up on technology, even use BibleMap.org hyper linking the biblical text to the locations named in a passage. You can even utilize GoogleEarth to show the modern day terrain.
With all this knowledge, bible maps are just one tool for understanding the texts. You can see Tyre is located on the coastline, far away from most of the other places frequented by Jesus and his disciples. Mark’s gospel also tips the reader off that Jesus has traveled far from his usual circuit of local Galilean villages. In Tyre, Jesus has traveled a distance so to have some rest and relaxation. Tyre is a wealthy city, primarily occupied by Gentiles. He likely stays with fellow Jews, but his time of R&R is cut short by the unexpected encounter with a Syrophoenician woman, desperate for his help in healing her demon-possessed child.
This particular passage makes a modern-day reader wince. The dialogue between Jesus and this woman is rather tense, and Jesus does not seem to square with the Jesus we tend to tell our children about. Unless it involves chasing moneychangers out of the Temple, our stories of Christ do not revolve around the Lord being angry or being so brusque. Jesus tends to be the benevolent figure of the Flannel-graph of years ago, and therefore, such passages of the Gospel remind us that the gospels are richly textured and complex. To read the gospels, even Mark with its plain and straightforward style, you really need a good map to understand the type of spiritual terrain of Mark, or if you will, “the lay of the land” envisioned by Jesus’ ministry and proclamation of the Reign of God.
In this text, we encounter the need for a few other maps. Knowing where Tyre is located is helpful, however, we need to puzzle out the way through this text with other maps to guide us. In this one text, we encounter mountains and valleys separating a Syrophoenician woman’s desperation from a fair hearing by this Jewish teacher and healer looking just for a breather. To read this text, we need help seeing the terrain with different markers, charting our way through first century understandings of gender, religious worldviews, and even economics.
Modern readers struggle with this text, reading the text with eyes, ears, and hearts shaped, influenced, and perhaps wounded by the realities of living in a culture where women still struggle with invisibility in the public square, pay scale, career options, and even in the Church, lest we be remiss, the realities of even among Jesus’ followers, those who would support, overtly or covertly, the stained glass ceiling. This text sounds too familiar: a request is rebuffed or minimized, left aside in the order of “what really matters”.
The “map” of gender helps us see the tenacity and determination of the Syrophoenician woman, resolute in her task of ensuring her child’s wellbeing. She has heard of Jesus’ reputation as healer, indeed, his notoriety as one willing to go beyond the lines and barriers of his faith tradition’s majority teachings. Mark 7 is a study in contrasts: last week we heard of Jesus’ willingness to keep the faith in ways “off the map” kept by the Pharisees. This week, we encounter a text where the same Jesus, bushed from the village circuit, leaving for a place where he could go unnoticed.
The argument between the Gentile woman and the Jewish rabbi is artful as well as tense. In the first century, arguments carried especial importance, as one’s honor or shame in the eyes of others was determined by the skill of keeping ahead of your detractors in the battle of words. Here, Jesus uses rebuffing words that lack grace, yet the woman picks up on his diminutive words and turns them around. Here, in the midst of the gospels, with Jesus’ knack for besting Pharisees, Sadducees, and all the other hecklers in the crowd, Jesus concedes her point and heals the child from afar. As it has been written in modern day scholarship, this occasion is the only time Jesus “loses” a fight, and he is bested by the most unlikely source: a Gentile woman, who reminds him of his calling and the fullness of the Reign of God.
The gender map illumines the first footpath through this story. We turn now to the implications of a Gentile reminding Jesus of what he taught. To look at this passage with a map rendered by first century Jewish thought, one wonders if Mark offers a small joke, emphasizing the woman’s identity as “a Gentile, of Syrophoenician origin”. The narrative cues up that Jesus is out of his home territories, however, going to Tyre and encountering this woman, Jesus is shown here as encountering someone from the wrong side of the tracks. His “dog” comment resonates rudely to twenty-first century ears, and even in the first century, listeners would have heard this term as a put-down. Dogs were considered among the most unclean of animals. The argument Jesus uses keeps a sense of purity that seems a far cry from the Jesus among the Pharisees just a few verses ago. If anything, Jesus seems a study in contradictions here in Mark, chapter seven. He allows his disciples to be more common and less ritualized. Now he treats an outsider to Israel’s worldview with a rather insular “close the ranks and circle the wagons” attitude.
For Mark’s gospel, the text highlights many characters, major and minor, which encounter Jesus, yet respond differently to his message. Jesus struggles to have his message understood by the Temple elite, the Roman and Jerusalem authorities, the various religious groups, and even his own disciples. Elizabeth Struthers Malbon demonstrates in her reading of Mark’s gospel the minor characters, the one-note, almost cameo appearance folks are the ones who recognize Jesus and his true identity, authority, and power. Look at the healings, and it is the leper, the woman with hemorrhaging, the blind persons, and all the other who cross the stage of the gospel just in brief scenes, who are the ones with the lines that really tell the story being performed by Mark’s cast of characters. Malbon observes, “The minor characters whom [Jesus] has healed exemplify faith in Jesus’ power and authority” (In the Company of Jesus, p. 199). Scholar Mitzi Minor likewise observes,
Where God’s realm spreads, there is a marvelous breakthrough in the struggle against oppressive restriction on human life. Through the transforming even t of the miracle, people are freed from bondage and made whole. (From The Spirituality of Mark, Westminster/John Knox, 1996, p. 51)
The Syrophoenician woman carries the distinction of being the only person in Mark’s entire gospel that calls Jesus “Lord”. Our English translations tend to use the “Sir” form, but the Greek word (kyrios) is there in the ancient manuscripts, attesting to the seriousness of this woman’s belief. She places herself in a posture of supplication, honoring Jesus’ authority and power. She takes Jesus’ identity as “Lord” very seriously, even to the point of engaging in the verbal sparring unfolding here. Women in the gospel of Mark may seem minor characters, yet again and again, they are strong advocates for Jesus’ vision of the Reign of God that “has come near” (Mark 1:15). From the longer ending to Mark’s gospel, we also learn that it will be Mary Magdalene, another minor character, who proclaims the resurrection first, despite her news being dismissed by the inner circle of disciples. I keep an icon of Mary Magdalene proclaiming the Easter good news in my office. She tells the story with great confidence, and the men look rather disbelievingly at her. It is a good reminder of the great witness Baptists often have been party to silencing, all in the name of keeping the pulpit and the ministry restricted to whom they believe God has called rather than those who God has called.
One final map is less obvious, perhaps lost in the midst of the more evident needs this text presents regarding help navigating issues of gender and religion. The final map is one of economics. The German New Testament scholar Gerd Theissen notes Tyre was a well-populated and wealthy coastal city. It was “upper Galilee” who supplied the demand of the coast cities. “In periods of crisis or food shortage, the populace of the hinterlands may have resented producing goods for the wealthy cities” (Theissen’s argument is traced by Pheme Perkins, in “Mark”, New Interpeter’s Bible, Vol. IX, p. 610). A Galilean would have carried a bit of a chip on the shoulder, dealing with a Gentile from a more privileged economic stance, a bit of underlying chronic irritation about the power dynamic and financial control being in the hands of outsiders.
The preacher Jeremiah Wright (a controversial name from last year’s political battles) spoke at Riverside Church in 2006. He told stories about his primarily African American congregation in Chicago dealing with a changing neighborhood, and despite a strong identification with issues of inclusion and racial justice, Wright found some of his congregants murmuring about the neighborhood’s demographics shifting with an influx of Asian American owned businesses. Wright highlighted the difficulties of congregants struggling to see beyond their own biases, treating others in ways that they themselves would not want to be treated.
The economic map is a lesser trail to follow, however, one sees the multiple challenges the Syrophonecian woman undertook to cross the gulfs of invisibility, insularity, and ideology to show her faith in Jesus. It is a complex story Mark gives us to ponder, and we learn yet again that the gospel is not easily tamed. It takes maps to get us places, yet we cannot take any one map as the final authority on the terrain you encounter.
A few years back, rural Kansas had a bit of an identity crisis. New regulations for emergency response systems required a standardization of road names. My father sat on the board selecting new names for old dirt roads. It was challenging, as the committee had to create names compliant with the new standards in mind as well as the painful experience of changing the names of roads sometimes long known by locals by names that passed down the generations.
One reality of these renaming or remapping of the locality was to level the playing field for all persons. If there was a new resident, how would they know the local names well enough to tell a EMT how to get to a house. Directions dependent on “turn left at Belknap Corner and you’ll find the Hugenots living on the old Jacot homestead” required a great deal of insider knowledge. New maps may not recall and recollect certain memories of the past or keep traditions, yet at the same time, it allows everyone to know where they are going.
Christianity has a map that we all struggle to follow. It’s called the gospel.
